Skip to main content

Solo Seder with Reb Shlomo



It wasn't supposed to be, really. I intended for Vanĕk the coonhound to play the roles of a small host of seder participants, but he woofed down one big piece of matzah and decided to limit his participation to reclining on the couch and watching out for Eliyahu.

It is the first night of Passover, and I am alone. Not  getting invited to a seder is perfectly understandable. Firstly, I'm not really anyone's family. And, secondly, who wants to invite someone like me? "She'll come for a short while, sit there silently, and then find a pretext to leave early." That's me, and that's what they say--on a good day. It's awkward for everyone. "She's always so serious, and so depressed." That's me.

If this all sounds a lot like self-pity, well, there is that, yes. "Poor-me-ism" is a definite part of my condition. I could/should have held a seder of my own, found someone else who had nowhere to go. There's always enough time to do something, even if if wouldn't have been a great feast with the fluffiest matzah balls and a main course to go down in history. "Sadness is the greatest sin," said Rabbi Nachman of Bratslav. I have both resented and loved him for that statement ever since I first read it.

I used to be very serious about seders, ask too much of both myself and everyone else. I refused to accept that for most people it really is just about the food, and about having a good time with friends and family. For me it was not about singing and joy, but about the journey of our souls from the narrow place of Mitzrayim to transcendent freedom, about ridding the heart of all its chometz, its bloat, about sharing deep confessions and deeper hopes and aspirations. Deep, but not so joyous.

One year, after a vigorously, albeit slightly chaotic rendition of Chad Gadya, one young adult expressed dismay that a child should be sold for two zuzim (!) Hm. Are you getting the idea that I'm an intellectual snob? Well, yes, there is that. Even though I have come to realize that I'm actually not as much of an intellectual as I liked to believe, but the snobbish bit seems to be hanging on. And so I secretly roll my eyes when university-educated young people don't know that a "kid" is not only a kid.

It may have something to do with English not being my native language, and with being a convert. Both make for, or exacerbate, a pre-existing fanatical streak in people.

Prompted by a friend, at my seder I planned to explore the leitmotif of "the stranger" that runs through the haggadah. If having been strangers in the land of Egypt is the prerequisite for being able to relate to other strangers, must we somehow always remain outsiders, never quite at home, quite integrated, or else lose the ability to understand those who are "other"? If we were to fit in utterly, get too comfortable in our skin and our life ...?

So, you see, it was going to be quite a serious affair with me and the dog that evening, and who can blame the dog for bowing out. But first there was a practical matter to take care of, as even a solo seder where food is incidental needs some basic accoutrements. So off I went in my pickup to the edge of the big city. Supermarkets out here in the country don't carry matzah. Back with my treasure, I prepared thin vegetable soup and charoset. I lit candles, and picked a haggadah from my collection: The Carlebach Haggadah.

Now, Reb Shlomo was a holy man. But he would have understood--maybe even encouraged--my taking a slightly strange approach to the solo seder. Instead of reading the actual text, I read his commentary. Every word of it. And forgot completely about my theme and the seder of the seder. I had some matzah, piled on the horseradish, and set my tastebuds dancing with heaping spoonfuls of charoset. I am a lousy cook, but my charoset is the sweetest thing in this world.

Reb Shlomo told me stories about rebbes who are long gone, about people who say "gevalt!" a lot, about poor people and rich people, about family, about the sin of sadness, the need for us to sing a new song, and about the One who never leaves us alone, unless we choose to walk away. I heard his music in every word, felt his love of stories and of people--the ones who know, the ones who don't, and event he ones who like to think they know.

Thank you, Rebbe.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

We're okay!!

We're okay, we say, we're well; zooming to see friends, it's great,  we're smiling, waving, smiling.  Smiling. And all around our elders trapped in airless rooms with only one way out: in body bags. Curbside the freezer trucks are waiting. Remember what it's like to hug,  to kiss, to be so close we dreamt each other's dreams? Will we remember--if we live? And will the woods be green again this spring? Will God forgive us our sins?

Teshuvah

  Photo Sasha Freemind on unsplash “Repentance,” like most words that have come into the English language from Latin, is thin on emotion, feeling. There is something cerebral about it that does not capture the sorrow, the regretting, the regressing to the fervored childlike promises of I’m sorry, I won’t do it again. But lashuv , to go back, means not only ”to regret,” it also means “to return.” This translation captures the hope that going back is always possible: going back to a pre-lapsarian world in which our wrongdoings are gone, in which we have not yet missed the mark ( cheit , the word for sin, being an archery term), in which broken relationships are healed without leaving scars, in which we ourselves are innocent again, having said No to the apple and the knowledge of good and evil. Yet somehow the notion of returning implies a place or a state of being to which we can return, as we move from the here and now to the there and then. But can we? How do I return when I a...

Something About Spring

There's something about spring.... Trees and shrubs madly competing to get all their leaves out first, big, fat, lush; grass turning too green, then being outdone by the too-yellow of a carpet of dandelion; tulips burning up the near-empty garden beds with hues of deep purple and barnfire reds. It's all somehow too much. And people, too, popping out of their sealed houses, shivering in thin shirts and sandals with grim determination, trying to ignore the hard spring breeze. In all that rushing towards new life, that frenzy seemingly shared by all living things, with the swallows repairing last year's nests, and the Canada Geese squatting in the middle of the hayfield, or even by the side of the road to get the new crop of children out ... in all that there is also denial, a forgetting of what fails to return, what has quietly ceased during autumn and winter: plants that went underground and have failed to rise again, animals whose last breath rode away on the stiff winds of...